Gay Key West

Directory of Restaurants & Caterers

2 Cents
Phone: 305-414-8626
416 Applerouth Ln
Local gastro pub with full service bar

915 Bistro and Wine Bar
Phone: 305-296-0669 * Fax: 305-296-0695
915 Duval Street
“What could be dreamier than a leisurely evening on the side porch of a dignified Victorian house, sharing a string of plates? Stuart Kemp has created a winner with NineOneFive.” NY Times review.

Abbondanza Italian Restaurant
Phone: 305-292-1199
1208 Simonton Street
Winner of "The People's Choice" Award for Favorite Italian Restaurant in Key West for many years, invites you to enjoy the charm of our Old Town location.

Phone: 305-294-6565
615 Duval Street
Celebrating 32 seasons this warm, elegant restaurant is a landmark. Everything at Antonia’s Key West is homemade and prepared to order by our European-trained chefs. Be our guest for lunch or dinner.

Azur Restaurant
Phone: 305-292-2987
425 Grinnell Street
Conveniently located in the heart of Old Town, AZUR Restaurant is the locals’ and visitors’ favorite for creative Mediterranean specialties. Best brunch on the island.

Banana Cafe Restaurant
Phone: 305-294-7227 * Fax: 30-294-7228
1215 Duval Street
Bonjour! Banana Cafe Restaurant Francais. Delicious Breakfast Lunch 8 am -3 p.m dinner from 6 to 10 p.m Tuesday to Saturday.

Better Than Sex Dessert Restaurant
Phone: 305-296-8102
531 Truman Avenue
A fabulous dessert restaurant in an intimate setting.

Blue Mojito Bar and Grill at the Hyatt
Phone: 305-809-4000
601 Front Street, Key West
A sophisticated Key West bar in a resort setting overlooking the Gulf of Mexico at the Hyatt Resort and Spa.

Conch Republic Seafood Company
Phone: 305-294-4403
631 Greene Street
Enjoy our spacious waterfront setting where the atmosphere is like a trip in a time machine to the way Key West used to be.

Destination Catering & Events
Phone: 305-517-6513
1200 4th St. #171, Key West, FL 33040
A full service caterer with the ability to prepare the entire menu on site by culinary experts with a combined experience of more than 50 years. From privae chef to a 1000 guests.

Deuce's "Off the Hook" Grill
Phone: 305-414-8428
728 Simonton Street, Key West, FL 33040
Small seafood and raw bar restaurant with gourmet pizzas. Open for breakfast, lunch, dinner. 7 days a week.

Flamingo Crossing Homemade Ice Cream
Phone: 305-296-6124 * Fax: 305-292-2220
1105 Duval Street
Homemade ice creams & sorbets - retail and wholesale. Specializing in tropical flavors in addition to your favorites.

Frenchie's Cafe
Phone: 305.396.7124
529 United St., Key West, FL 33040
A truely French Cafe. Sandwiches, Salads, Quiches and Pastries. Dine in, carry out, and delivery available.

Goldman's Bagel Deli
Phone: 305-294-3354
2796 N. Roosevelt Blvd
Local deli & bagel bakery

Hard Rock Café
Phone: 305-293-0230
313 Duval Street
Legendary chain located in historic mansion fronting Duval Street.

Island House Café & Bar
Phone: 305-294-6284 * Fax: 305-292-0551
1129 Fleming Street
The Café and Bar at Island House. Dine under lazy ceiling fans and rustling palms looking at naked men in the pool. The cuisine is creative and sophisticated. Extensive wine list.

Johnny Rockets
Phone: 305-735-4831
217 Duval Street
Family American Restaurant with Full Bar and Private Dining and Meeting Rooms

Key Plaza Creperie
Phone: 305-517-6032
1105 Key Plaza, Key West, FL 33040
New uptown restaurant-creperie. Open daily 7am-5pm. Serving breakfast,panini,salads,sweet & savory crepes all day. Great coffee - specialty french press coffee & tea.

Key West Cakes
Phone: 305-296-4162
1014 White St
The best cakes on the island! Delicious cakes for all special occasions. Yummy cupcakes, pot pies, and lasagna too.

La Te Da Restaurant
Phone: 305-296-6706
1125 Duval Street
The Restaurant at La Te Da offers a relaxed, elegant island ambience along with truly inspired cuisine. Recharge or unwind while indulging in a unique dining experience.

Phone: 305-292-4606 & 305-394-7469 * Fax: 305-292-7958
700 Duval Street KIey West, Flordia 33040
Mangoes proudly serves a delicious selection of Floribbean and American Foods. Enjoy outdoor patio seating on Duval Street or inside our beautiful air-conditioned dining room.

Martin's on Duval
Phone: 305-295-0111
917 Duval Street
As soon as one arrives in Martin’s, one feels surrounded by European sophistication with a touch of the playfulness of the tropics– just like our menu!

Pepe's Cafe
Phone: 305-294-7192
806 Caroline St.
Established in 1909, Pepe's is the eldest eating house in the Florida Keys. Open EVERY day and serving breakfast, lunch and dinner. American fare.

Pincher's Crab Shack
Phone: 305-440-2179
712 Duval Street
Family-owned restaurant specializing in fresh seafood. "You can't fake fresh."

Ricky's Blue Heaven
Phone: 305-296-8666
729 Thomas St
The specialties are Caribbean cuisine, sea food and vegetarian dishes.

Salute on the Beach
Phone: 305-292-1117
1000 Atlantic Blvd
Featuring lighter, Caribbean-influenced takes on Italian classics—with fresh breads, vegetables and local seafood—Salute! On The Beach is a Key West tradition for locals and visitors alike.

Santiago's Bodega
Phone: 3052967691 * Fax: 3052967691
207 Petronia Street Suite 101
A wonderful assortment of small plates await you at this tapas-style eatery, a well seasoned combination of dishes, great soups, salads, and a remarkable wine list to compliment.

Shameless Lounge
Phone: 305-296-2033
610 Greene Street
A Key West Style Gastro Pub with Speakeasy Vibe featuring Shamelessly Great Spirits, Eats and Entertainment

SHOR American Seafood Grill
Phone: 305-809-4000
601 Front Street
Take in million dollar bay views and savor the freshest catch from land and sea in this extraordinary Key West restaurant.

Six-Toed Cat
Phone: 305.294.3318 * Fax: 305.294.3319
823 Whitehead St., Key West, FL 33040
You really can't leave Key West without trying Six-Toed Cat's world famous Lobster Benedict, Stuffed French French Toast or our delicious breakfasts and lunches.

Small Chef at Large
Phone: 305-294-1943
2200 N. Roosevelt Blvd.
One of this island’s favorite caterers for wedding receptions, private parties, fundraising galas, special events, corporate events, lunch meetings, conferences, home entertaining and more!

Square One
Phone: 305-296-4300
1075 Duval Street, C12
Restaurant and catering - global and innovative new american cuisine.

Thai Cuisine
Phone: 305.294.9424 * Fax: 905.294.6301
513 Greene St., Key West, FL 33040

The Boathouse Bar & Grill
Phone: (305) 294-9191
700 Front Street at the Historic Seaport
Casual dockside dining featuring happy hour drink and food specials and comfortable pub atmosphere. Same owners and chefs as The Commodore Waterfront Restaurant upstairs.

The Commodore Waterfront Restaurant
Phone: 305-294-9191 * Fax: 305-294-9191
700 Front Street
Waterside dining; fresh lobster & stone crabs (when in season), local seafood, prime rib and filet mignon are among the fine entrees offered.

Three Fine Cooks
Phone: 305-395-1048 * Fax: 305-745-3565
513 Fleming Street, Unit 4
Enjoy your Guests, We'll Do The Rest! We specialize in Cocktail Parties, Dinner Parties, Rehearsal Diners & Commitment Ceremonies of All Sizes.